Hertz Ultimate Choice Guide [Locations, Cars, Eligibility]

Hertz introduced Ultimate Choice to compete with National Car Rental, and allow Gold members to choose any car in the aisle at select airport locations.

The selection in each aisle depends on your Hertz Status (Gold, Five Star, or President’s Circle).

I love Ultimate Choice as a President’s Circle member because Hertz typically places Mustangs, Land Rovers, Infinitis, Camaros, and other high-end cars on the President’s Circle Aisle.

However, Ultimate Choice is not available at non-airport or neighborhood locations. 

Eligibility for Hertz Ultimate Choice

To be eligible for Hertz Ultimate Choice you need to 

  1. Make a reservation with your Hertz Gold account; and
  2. Book a midsize/intermediate class car or higher. 

Hertz sometimes calls a midsize a “Medium Sedan,” but just look for a Group “C” car. 

You can also opt-out of Ultimate Choice by booking a Minivan, Truck, SUV, Luxury, Prestige, or Adrenaline car. These options will be much more expensive, but you can guarantee you will have that type of car when you arrive.

Hertz Midsize

If you book something lower than a midsize or a “Manger Special,” Hertz will automatically assign you a car that won’t be located in the President’s Circle, Five Star, or Gold Plus areas. 

If you book a midsize or higher, you should see your name an electronic board of names telling you to go to the Aisle associated with your elite status. Or an email telling you to head to a certain aisle.

You can then pick any car in that section, or a car in a lower status aisle. For example, if you were President’s Circle status, you could also pick a car in the Five Star section. That could be helpful if you wanted an SUV or Minivan and there were none in the President’s Circle section.

Hertz Ultimate Choice Map

Hertz Ultimate Choice Airport Locations

Hertz Ultimate Choice is available at 58 airports in the United States, and in Toronto, Canada, including: 

  • Albuquerque
  • Atlanta
  • Austin
  • Baltimore
  • Boston
  • Burbank
  • Charlotte
  • Chicago O’Hare
  • Chicago Midway
  • Cincinnati
  • Cleveland
  • Dallas/Fort Worth
  • Dallas Love
  • Denver
  • Detroit
  • El Paso
  • Fort Lauderdale
  • Fort Myers
  • Hartford
  • Houston Hobby
  • Houston Intercontinental
  • Indianapolis
  • Kansas City
  • Las Vegas
  • Los Angeles
  • Memphis
  • Miami
  • Milwaukee
  • Minneapolis-St. Paul
  • Nashville
  • New Orleans
  • Newark
  • New York JFK
  • New York LaGuardia
  • Oakland
  • Oklahoma City
  • Ontario, CA
  • Omaha, NE
  • Orlando
  • Philadelphia
  • Phoenix
  • Pittsburgh
  • Portland
  • Providence
  • Raleigh-Durham
  • Richmond
  • Sacramento
  • Salt Lake City
  • San Antonio
  • San Diego
  • San Francisco
  • San Jose
  • Seattle-Tacoma
  • St. Louis
  • Tampa
  • Washington Dulles
  • Washington Reagan
  • West Palm Beach
  • Toronto

Cars in the Ultimate Choice Aisles

The cars available in the Ultimate Choice aisles will heavily depend on your status level with Hertz.

Hertz places the best cars in the President’s Circle aisle, followed by the 5-Star Aisle.

It also depends on the airport location. Some airports are much better than others. I’ve had the best luck with morning pickups, and airports in Florida, California, Arizona, Phoenix, and Las Vegas. 

You can find the best and most recent information on each airport on FlyerTalk’s individual Hertz airport locations threads.

Premium Upgrades

If you don’t like the cars in your Ultimate Choice aisle, you can do a Premium Upgrade for $25 per day as a President’s Circle member and $35 per day as a Five Star or Gold member.

The cars in the Premium Upgrade section are typically $40,000+ cars and SUVs including Mercedes Benz, Range Rovers, and luxury convertibles.

Hertz Limited Edition Camaro ZL1 Available at CLT, RSW, LAS, MIA, MCO, and PHX.

Sign up for our Daily Points newsletter